“Why can’t they leave me alone?”
Despite financial issues that went back nearly a decade and the occasional natural disaster, Return To Sleepaway Camp managed to be released direct to video in 2008. The film is a direct sequel to the cult classic Sleepaway Camp (1983). The film features the return of the original film’s writer and director, Robert Hiltzik, original film actors Jonathan Tiersten and Paul DeAngelo, and (spoiler alert) the triumphant return of Felissa Rose to the role of Angela Baker! The film also features Vincent Pastore, Isaac Hayes (in a small role), Adam Wylie, Erin Broderick, Kate Simses, Jackie Tohn, and Michael Gibney.
In the film, troubled camper Alan (Gibney) is the victim of relentless bullying at the hands of his fellow campers. He dishes out quite a bit of his own mischief as well, but the other campers (and some of the staff) humiliate him at every turn. As the film moves along, people begin to die in strange ways. When bodies start to pile up, Sheriff Jerry is brought in to investigate the killings. Ronnie (DeAngelo), who was a camp counselor at Camp Arawak when Angela Baker went on her brutal killing spree, believes that Angela has returned. Everybody else has different theories as to what is going on at the camp. Is Angela back to kill again? Perhaps her cousin, Ricky, has picked up her cause? Watch Return To Sleepaway Camp to find out who the killer really is!
This film is bad. I hate to say it because I love the original film and have grown fond of the two Sleepaway Camp sequels, Unhappy Campers and Teenage Wasteland, starring Pamela Springsteen in the role of Angela. Those two films went a little heavier on the humor than the original film, but they were still enjoyable for the most part. I have not seen Sleepaway Camp IV: The Survivor, so I cannot comment on that particular film at the moment. It was nice to see Felissa Rose, even if it was briefly, back on the screen and I also appreciated the return of Tiersten and DeAngelo. None of the kids in the film are likeable, but I did enjoy counselors Petey (Simses) and Linda (Tohn), although they portrayed characters on different ends of of the spectrum. Petey was quick to defend Alan whenever he screwed up and eventually becomes a suspect in the murders. Linda feels a lot like the original film’s Judy (Karen Fields). Had that character survived the first film, I believe that Linda is exactly who that character would have become.
The practical effects are pretty good and the kills are okay, but overall this film feels like something that could have been so much better. The acting is hit-and-miss and the reveal at the end lacks the punch of the original movie’s legendary reveal. If you just have to watch every Sleepaway Camp film, give it a look. If you love Felissa Rose, watch it. Otherwise, this isn’t a film that I necessarily recommend.
Thanks for checking out my review. I hope to continue posting more often as this year continues.























































