“The balance must be respected.”
We all age. We get wrinkles. Our bodies begin hurting in ways we never dreamed of when we were young. Eventually we become senior citizens and, like it or not, society looks down its nose at a lot of us. In the glitzy world of film and television, getting old comes with potentially deep losses. Actors are almost always expected to be young and attractive and when that first crack of the skin appears on an actor’s face, especially on an actress’ face, the role offers and callbacks start to dwindle. Such is the situation that fifty year old Elisabeth (Demi Moore) finds herself in in 2024’s The Substance. The film is written and directed by Coralie Fargeat, who is known for Revenge (2017) and Reality+ (2014).
Spoilers ahead!!!!
In the film, former award-winning film actress Elisabeth finds herself unceremoniously dumped by the studio that produces her workout show due to the fact that she’s too old in the eyes of Harvey (Dennis Quaid) and he wants a younger, prettier “girl” to replace her. After getting in a car accident on the way home, Elisabeth is offered the substance by a nurse. When she arrives at home, she stands in the mirror, completely nude, and looks at her aging body. She ultimately contacts the producer of the substance and injects it into her body, resulting in the “birth” of Sue (Margaret Qualley), a younger version of Elisabeth who is catapulted into the spotlight by Harvey.
The substance comes with a strict set of rules. Elisabeth and Sue must switch between one another every seven days. One remains in a comatose-like state while the other gets seven days of freedom. Sue embraces her newfound popularity while Elisabeth grows more and more jealous of her popularity. Sue begins to push the limits of the rules, taking more and more time from Elisabeth and accelerating the aging process. Problems begin to ramp up for Elisabeth, as her aging gets out of control and Sue’s popularity continues to skyrocket. The big issue here, though, is that Elisabeth and Sue are the same person in two very different bodies. As Sue falls in love with her new life, Elisabeth begins to make Sue’s life miserable. The duo ultimately have a massive face-off, resulting in a new version of them, Monstro Elisasue, to be born. The creature lurches onto the stage on New Year’s Eve, a night that was supposed to shoot Sue into greater stardom, and blasts the crowd with blood, crying for acceptance. In the end, Elisabeth is reduced to a gooey face that is squashed on her own star on the walk of fame.
While the film definitely has its highlights, for the most part, The Substance lacks…..substance. The story is nothing new and something that has been around since films have been around. Actors get older and begin losing roles to younger actors. Older actors will go to great lengths to maintain their youthful appearance. The film highlights this, especially the toll it takes on actresses, and the way that many corporate sleazeballs objectify women. On the other hand, it shows how actors will turn on others in order to get what they want. There are no real heroes in this film. Everyone is tragic and/or unlikeable. Fargeat’s direction and shots are all taken from other films and directors. You don’t need a very sharp eye to see influences from films like The Shining, A Clockwork Orange, and more. It also draws influence from works such as The Picture Of Dorian Gray and Carrie. The film also has very limited dialogue and sluggish pacing as well, making it a tough watch.
One thing that the film does get right is the practical effects. Almost all of the film’s effects are realized using makeup, prosthetics, puppets, and appliances. The Elisasue creature looks great and appears to draw influence from The Thing, Basket Case, and other gruesome creatures. I also want to applaud the performance of Demi Moore. Although she was portraying a character that just turned fifty, Moore was actually sixty-one at the time of filming. She still looks great, and much like her character in the film, she’s had enhancements over the years to retain her youth. That said, she appears completely nude multiple times in the film and she does show her age. Don’t get me wrong, I’m not trying to say anything derogatory about her, it’s just that in one particular scene, perhaps the best scene in the film, her character is looking in the mirror at all of her imperfections. The camera pans around her entire body, revealing every wrinkle and crease. It’s sad and beautiful at the same time. Elisabeth is sad that she is aging, but it is beautiful that Moore is willing to bare her own aging to the world.
Ultimately, The Substance is just one more in a long line of body horror films that has flashes of brilliance, amazing effects, but ultimately falls under the weight of its own story. The ending completely derails any momentum built earlier in the film and brings a ho-hum experience to a brutal halt.
I don’t necessarily recommend this film, but if you grew up watching Moore on the big screen like I did, it might be worth your time. Thanks for reading my review.








































































